Field Sobriety Tests in Ohio: How They Work and How They Are Challenged

Field sobriety tests are often the most important evidence in an OVI case, especially when there is no breath test or the result is close to the limit. They are also where many cases are won, because the tests only count if the officer gave and scored them the way the national standards require. Attorney Dimitrios Makridis is a member of the DUI Defense Lawyers Association and reviews the video of every test in every OVI case he handles. Call (330) 394-1587 for a free consultation.

The Three Standardized Field Sobriety Tests

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) trains officers on three standardized tests. Each has set instructions, set clues the officer looks for, and a set number of clues that counts as a “fail.”

TestWhat the officer looks forCluesDecision point
Horizontal gaze nystagmus (HGN)Involuntary jerking of the eyes as they follow a pen or light from side to side: lack of smooth pursuit, distinct jerking when the eye is held at the far side, and jerking that starts before the eye reaches about 45 degrees.6 (3 per eye)4 or more clues
Walk and turnNine heel-to-toe steps along a line, a specific turn and nine steps back: losing balance during instructions, starting too soon, stopping, missing heel-to-toe, stepping off the line, using arms for balance, an improper turn, or the wrong number of steps.82 or more clues
One-leg standStanding on one foot with the other about six inches off the ground and counting out loud for about 30 seconds: swaying, using arms for balance, hopping, or putting the foot down.42 or more clues

NHTSA’s own research reports these tests as indicators, not proof. None of them measures how much you had to drink, and none of them is designed to measure impairment from marijuana or other drugs by itself.

Why Field Sobriety Tests Often Go Wrong

  • The officer has to follow the standards. Under R.C. 4511.19(D)(4)(b), an officer can testify about the results only if the tests were given in substantial compliance with the testing standards in effect at the time. Wrong instructions, wrong timing or wrong scoring can keep the results out of court.
  • Conditions matter. The walk and turn and one-leg stand are supposed to be done on a dry, hard, level, non-slippery surface with adequate lighting. Roadside gravel, a sloped shoulder, wind, cold, passing traffic and flashing lights all affect performance.
  • Not everyone is a good candidate. NHTSA training recognizes that people over 65 and people with back, leg or inner-ear problems may have trouble with the balance tests even when sober. Heels over about two inches should come off.
  • The eye test has medical explanations. Before HGN, the officer is supposed to check for equal pupil size, equal tracking and resting nystagmus, which can point to a medical condition or injury rather than alcohol. Some medications and conditions cause nystagmus too.
  • The video tells the story. Cruiser and body camera video often shows a different picture than the police report: steady balance, clear speech, or instructions given too fast or not at all.

Non-Standardized Tests and Portable Breath Tests

Officers sometimes add tests that are not part of the NHTSA battery, such as reciting the alphabet, counting backward, the finger-to-nose test or estimating 30 seconds with your eyes closed. These tests were not validated the way the three standardized tests were, and their weight can be challenged.

A portable breath test (the small handheld device at the roadside) is different from the breath test machine at the station. In Ohio, a portable breath test result is generally used only to help decide whether there is probable cause to arrest, not to prove your alcohol level at trial.

In drug OVI cases, officers may use drug recognition training (ARIDE or DRE), which adds steps like checking pupil size, muscle tone and pulse. These evaluations are also open to challenge, especially in marijuana cases. See our page on marijuana and drug OVI.

Field Sobriety Test Questions

Do I have to do field sobriety tests in Ohio?

No. Field sobriety tests are voluntary, and refusing them is not the same as refusing the breath, blood or urine test after arrest, so it does not trigger the implied consent license suspension. The officer can still arrest you based on other observations.

Can I fail the tests and still win my case?

Yes. If the tests were not given in substantial compliance with NHTSA standards, the results can be excluded. Even when they come in, the video, the conditions and your own health can explain the clues.

Does Ohio use the 2023 NHTSA manual?

Ohio courts look at the NHTSA standards that were in effect when the tests were given. Officers are trained from the current NHTSA manual, and comparing what the officer did against that manual is part of our review.

Should I tell the officer about a medical condition?

You can, and it is often helpful to have it on video. Injuries, inner-ear problems, eye conditions and some medications affect these tests.

Arrested for OVI? Try our free OVI Case Review to see your deadlines and the issues worth a closer look, or call Makridis Law Firm at (330) 394-1587.

Based on the NHTSA DWI Detection and Standardized Field Sobriety Testing curriculum and Ohio Revised Code 4511.19(D)(4)(b). This page provides general information, not legal advice.